PuzzlePup vs Native Pet: Allergy Chew Comparison
A closer look at Allergy chews
Choose with the whole label in view.
Two jars can look similar and contain different formulas. Compare the format, ingredients, chew count, and directions for your dog before you choose.
PuzzlePup Allergy Soft Chews put approximately 60 chews in a 180 g jar, with the complete active and inactive ingredient lists printed on the label.
Specific products. Specific differences.
PuzzlePup and Native Pet, side by side.
This compares PuzzlePup Allergy Soft Chews with Native Pet Allergy Chews. These are different formulas.
PuzzlePupSoft chews
Native PetAir-dried chews
PuzzlePupApproximately 60 chews; 180 g net weight
Native Pet60 chews
PuzzlePupPostbiotic, quercetin, turmeric root powder, ashwagandha root extract, and bovine colostrum.
Native PetBovine colostrum, spirulina, dried yeast fermentate, algae oil, and Bacillus coagulans.
PuzzlePupUnder 25 lb: 1 chew. 25–50 lb: 1–2 chews. Over 50 lb: 2–3 chews. Follow the full label.
Native PetThe listed directions vary by weight and use a larger daily quantity for the first two weeks. Read the product’s current directions before estimating how long a container lasts.
Selected ingredients are examples, not complete lists or a ranking of effectiveness. Different ingredients and amounts cannot establish which product will work better for an individual dog.
Inside PuzzlePup’s formula
The amounts are there to check.
Our two-chew serving lists 250 mg postbiotic, 100 mg ashwagandha root extract, 100 mg turmeric root powder, and 75 mg quercetin, among the complete nine-actives formula.
The listed amounts are for two chews. Use the daily amount on the jar for your dog’s weight.
Explore all three PuzzlePup formulas
Open the complete PuzzlePup Allergy label
Read the full ingredient list, directions, and cautions. Bring the label to your veterinarian when discussing whether a supplement fits your dog.
Compare the jar you will actually buy.
Native Pet’s 60-count Allergy product is an air-dried chew. Its listed ingredients include chicken, bovine colostrum, and porcine gelatin; check its full ingredient list if your dog has a known sensitivity.
Use the current delivered price and the label-directed daily quantity when comparing value. With approximately 60 PuzzlePup chews, one a day is about 60 days, two a day is 30 days, and three a day is 20 days.
Comparison checked October 5, 2026. Sources: the physical PuzzlePup label shown above and Native Pet Allergy Chews at Tractor Supply. Formulas, sizes, and offers can change; check the package you purchase. Native Pet is a trademark of its owner. PuzzlePup is not affiliated with or endorsed by Native Pet.